Grown-Up Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

When I first read that Chris Kimball had a recipe for grilled cheese sandwiches, I thought he had gone off the deep end. Next he’ll be telling me the best method for pouring a bowl of breakfast cereal. But then I watched the episode of America’s Test Kitchen (ATK) where they interviewed people who were obviously just as skeptical as I was about using a recipe for grilled cheese sandwiches. Per the recipe, I found cheddar that was aged for one year (heading the advice to avoid cheddar aged for longer; as it won’t melt well). Of course the Brie was easier to track down. While the recipe doesn’t take much more time, ATK claimed 5 extra minutes, it does make a considerably mess (food processor, bowl, sheet pan and wire rack). I was not expecting these grilled cheese to have a classic flavor profile, but I was slightly disappointed that it failed to impress me. The flavors were different, but not necessarily better. The shallot and wine seemed a bit out-of-place. I liked the more expensive cheese, but the cheese slightly separated and oozed out too much. 3-1/2 stars.

Much ado about nothing

Much ado about nothing

Rating: 3-1/2 stars.
Cost: $6 for 4 sandwiches.
How much work? Low/Medium
How big of a mess?  Medium.
Started: 1pm. Ready: 1:45pm.

Chris Kimball’s original recipe is here. The descriptions of how I cooked it today are given below:

7-oz cheddar cheese (aged up to 1 year)
2-oz Brie cheese
2 tablespoons dry white wine or vermouth
1/2 shallot (4 teaspoons minced)
3 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
8 slices hearty white sandwich bread

  1. Either leave your cheddar and butter out on counter-top until it reaches room temperature or microwave for 30 seconds. Cut cheddar into 24 equal pieces. Cut away and discard rind from Brie. Mince your shallot.
  2. Add cheddar cubes, Brie and wine into food processor and process for about 25 seconds until forms a smooth paste. Add minced shallot and pulse 3 to 5 times until combined.
  3. Use a rubber spatula to combine the butter and mustard in small bowl.
  4. Line your counter-top with 18″ of parchment or wax paper. Evenly spread mustard/butter over 1 side of all 8 slices of bread.
  5. Flip 4 of the slices so that the buttered side faces down, and use your spatula/knife to evenly spread the cheese over the 4 slices. Close your sandwiches with the remaining 4 slices of bread.
  6. Place a 12″ non-stick skillet over medium burner and pre-heat for 2 minutes. You can test by flicking drops of water into pan and they should sizzle.
  7. Reduce burner to medium-low, and cook 2 or 3 sandwiches at a time. Cook for 6 to 9 minutes, occasionally moving the sandwiches to ensure they brown evenly. Flip sandwiches and brown for another 6 to 9 minutes.
  8. Remove sandwiches from skillet and allow to sit for 2 minutes before serving. The first sandwiches can be held in a 200-degree oven on a wire rack set in a baking sheet.

8 Responses to Grown-Up Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

  1. Jonny Rashid says:

    I’ve done a lot of variations on this and now this is my go-to grilled cheese recipe. Surprised you were disappointed! I also used homemade bread and didn’t bother to cut the rind off the cheese (my cheddar was six-months too).

  2. Susie says:

    I was so excited to see this in my email this morning since I planned to make these tonight! So disappointed to see it only 31/2 stars! Everyone who tested these on the show were impressed so I was anxious to give it a go. We have a diverse palate in my house so it will be interesting to see how they go over. Thanks for the reviews, I look forward to every recipe you make!

  3. jeanf says:

    I make the CI ones from The Best Recipe all the time. Very simple changes to my old method but great results. Brush bread with melted butter, use grated cheese (I use sharp) and grill on medium. Mine get melty (sometimes I add mozzarella and swiss) and crunchy. Perfect accompaniment to tomato soup.

  4. A says:

    I’ll keep it simple: This recipe was Phenomenal. Wonderful blend of flavors. I have done this several times and the people that I have served it to have loved it.

  5. Steph Fylpaa says:

    Add me to your list for recipes or blogs

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: